I have many compressors. I have 3 pedal boards and each has one, a stopmbox. The Wampler Ego is good and is buffered when on. The tone control gets way to bright, but the unit is quiet, not like a Dyancomp. And I have a Dynacomp from the 70's. The keeley 2 knob is good and cheap, but can be noisy is stacked with certain pedals.
I have found Boss pedals to be good and used to use one as an always on compressor. If you want a quite pedal that will squish, the Engineers Thumb is quite good. Then again, the Joe Meek Floor-Q flopped badly, but is really a good compressor. I am saying it is a good use buy.
I find compressors that are on the floor to be quite different, so it is difficult to recommend unless I know the application. Squeeze 80's country music, MXR Dynacomp and throw in a flanger. I have yet to see a stompbox compressor used in recording, but that doesn't mean anything cause I have never seen it. I am sure it is done.
I linked Preservation Sound's website as an aid and they have a lot of info on units. My Bass rig has a DBX 266 which is overkill, but I had it so I used it.
I have an old Dan Armstrong and Analogueman makes a version of this. His Bi-Comp is good as well. Most I consider a form of effect, but if'n you want to get chickins cluckin, and you want to build it, the Engineers Thumb is great. If you are recording, I retract all!