... Also, where can I get the proper optoisolator for this? All the ones at Mouser are LED driven. If I can't find one, I would be happy just to get the amp working without the hiss. ...
I'm not a good-enough resource, because I don't know anything about the rating of the original (meaning the incandescent bulb). If you knew what kind of bulb to use, you could cut open a neon roach, place the incandescent bulb in place of the neon one, and slide new heatshrink over it to make a proper unit.
If I had a string of christmas tree lights, I might steal a bulb out of it (one with wire leads coming out the end) and try it just to see if it worked.
I'm hoping someone who's faced this problem before will jump in (but Gibson amp experts seem few and far between).
With R36 disconnected, I am getting more gain on the reverb channel (same as the normal channel) and the reverb seems to be functioning properly.
Sumthin ain't right. R36 is 100k mix resistor running from the reverb channel's V4b, pin 1, to the 750k resistor on V4B, pin 6. If you unsolder either side of this resistor, the reverb channel should not feed into the output stage at all. If you accidentally unsolder
R35 (also 100k at V4B, pin 6), it should still kill the reverb channel because V4B will be disconnected from B+. That you get signal at all from the reverb channel is
no bueno.
The troubleshooting logic was to kill one channel while evaluating the other channel's gain/noise, so that we can find/fix the problem efficiently.
I state upfront I've never been inside this particular amp. But all the new 225P orange drops, and the mix of cloth and plastic insulated wire tells me someone's swapped a LOT of parts, and may have made some other changes.
I think you might need to trace everything to figure out what's same-as the schematic and what's been changed. I'm having trouble figuring out what's going on just from the pictures, just because some parts are obscured by wiring or other parts. The two thick wires in place of the trem roach will only work on the bulb side; the light-dependent resistor side can't be effectively replaced with a wire. It
should kill most of the reverb channel signal (or make it extremely muddy).
I'd probably remove those two thick wires, as well as C32 (the 0.022uF at the "top end" of those wires in the pic, by V3) and see what it sounds like.