"re: "is this a keeper?" ans. are you trying to make a silk purse out of a sow's ear? You could always pull the guts and build a JM clone. I see some really nice results from guys like Mark Moser over at Frugal Amps. Or, you could follow the trend which is to use the free listing feature at sneeze-bay and see if someone wants one for 6x what you paid. However, if it is the combo amp with 2x12s, you will have to ship it via OverTheRoad trucker because it prob. weighs as much as a Cummins diesel engine!"
Great post. It is very, very hard for the brain to make three decisions at once. The other day, I found two pieces of surplus gear. One has a pair of 6550's in it and 4 qty 12AX7 and other than some bizarre output transformer w/a output impedance of 500 or 600 ohms (guess) resembles nothing so much as a conventional chunky power amp. When I can buy something like that for $25, as I did, 1/4 the value of the two output tubes, I completely refuse to overthink what I might do with it.
The other piece has 5 qty 6C10's in it (which my Hickok 6000 tube tester cannot test, but I see no reason why I cannot fabricate a compactron socket thingy and test 3 qty 12AX7 [or whatever they are] sections one by one, and a pair of EL34's and a pair of EL84's. $25. Those compactrons go for >$30 each (used) on fleabay and so again, am I supposed to overthink this kind of thing?
You are talking about buying obvious value for 20 and 30 and fiddy bucks and if the thing turns out to destroy itself like the tape on Mission Impossible OR if it's worth 5x what you paid for it, it is not going to be a life changer. Don't overthink it. Go and do.