I think that what is happening is that the effects pedals, one or many or all of them, usually generate a glitch or a noise or whatever you want to call it when they are shut off. I have a POD and it makes a fearsome squawk when I turn it off....not a "thump" but a very high-pitched and high volume squeak that is positively annoying if I turn it off before doing anything to the amp. A real ear twister and maybe even a speaker-blower.
In your case, your amp remains "amping" a little bit even with B+ turned off (eg; standby) and draining fast...and you are getting that turn-off transient when you kill the power strip.
One solution IMO is to just wait more time in between stand-bying the amp and shutting off the strip. More like a full minute. It's of course dependent upon how fast your particular amp bleeds off B+ when switched to standby. Some: 5-10 seconds. Others: almost a minute. It has a lot to do with whether you have some form of bleeder resistor installed on the amp power supply. For example, on Twin Reverbs where you have those 2 qty 220K "balancing" resistors strapped parallel to the series-connected filter caps, those *do* function as a bleeder, but not a very "aggressive" one, as those R's only pull maybe a mil or so. Also consider: if the negative bias on the output tubes happens to fade a lot faster than the rest of the B+, the output section could probably amplify with a very low B+ of around 100 volts! Enough for one big "whump".