For Arts & Crafts-era furniture, you gotta go with quarter-sawn oak, with a dark stain.
You are correct in that much Craftsman/Arts & Crafts/Mission was done in q-sawn oak - when one thinks of this type of furniture, that is invariably the image that comes to mind. It is somewhat lost to history though that cherry was also quite common. A furniture making type guy I know insists that 40% of Stickley pieces were made in cherry - I can't verify that myself but he usually knows what he's spouting off about. Indeed a quick perusal of the current Stickley catalog shows that most items are available in both woods.
As I am more partial to cherry, and as I had exactly the pieces I needed in the basement, and as the cherry that I bought to make a Thomas Moser knockoff bed for my daughter needs to dry for another month, I leaped into making my cab yesterday. Here is what the side panels look like in clamps:

The slots are for Dominos - without a doubt the fastest and easiest way to join wood. Very high quality joins too.
Also, if you look carefully in the upper right, you can see a Partscaster in final setup - the product of a class in guitar making that I taught in Jan. The kids did really excellent work and made instruments that they can be proud of.