The term was clicking and rather than go through the process of eliminating that, I just pulled it out because it was tone sucking in the worst way. SO now I have no trem. I pull V5. The only thing wired to that socket is the heater.
It would have been nice to measure the trem oscillator's output at either the oscillator plate or the buffer cathode to know what the peak-to-peak voltage is. A true-RMS meter could give you an indication to start with (you'd need to do some math and assume a perfect sine wave to get the peak-to-peak voltage), or an o'scope could show you exactly.
That info could have been compared to the range of bias voltages needed to go from idle to full-off. Which is where I was going in trying to understand what is/isn't happening in the original trem circuit.
BTW: the Hoffman AB763 oscillator matches the
6G16 Vibroverb, not the blackface amps. But that's okay, because it was copying the 6G16's bias-vary trem.
I rolled tubes in the reverb recovery until I no longer had massive microphonics ... I'd love to use one of about 5 other tubes but they are all microphonic on the reverb return. Does the reverb return in the Hoffman design have a massive about of gain?
No, it exactly matches the 6G16 Vibroverb, except that the mixing of the reverb/dry matches the AB763. The Fender AB763 uses an 820Ω cathode resistor on the reverb return, where the 6G16/Hoffman AB763 uses a 1.5kΩ. I don't imagine that would make much difference, but you can try a resistor swap if you like.
... I also feel like I'm driving the reverb very hard and wonder if the tone would improve if I lowered the gain on that side. It does have a 12AT7 in that spot. I have tried 3 different tanks and they all sound overdriven to me. The reverbs in my other amps sound smoother in general. I ave the original tank, a brand spanking new MOD 3 spring long tank, and a 20 year old mojotone 3 spring short tank. If none of them sound right then I'd say it's not right. ...
I've only ever had reverb in original blackface/silverface amps, and with an Accutronics 6-spring tank in a reissue 6G15 Reverb unit. So I don't know how any of the modern tanks compare to any of those.
I know the '67 Super Reverb I used to own always seemed to have way too much reverb, the circuit had hiss if you turned the Reverb knob up at all, and was silly-cavernous at 4. I always kept the reverb turned down to 3 or below on that amp & let it be what it was; I never tied to "fix it". I only mention that to say your mental image of what it should sound like may be different from the reality of what the old amps actually were.
Regardless, there is a solution: look at the grid resistor for the 12AT7. It's a 1MΩ to ground. Temporarily swap a 1MΩ pot in place of that resistor, wired like a typical volume control. Now you exactly match the Dwell control on the Fender outboard reverb unit. Fiddle the pot until you find the amount of drive into the tank you want. Turn off the amp, and carefully measure the resistance from each outer lug to the wiper (which is feeding the 12AT7 grid). Replace the single 1MΩ resistor with 2 resistors matching your measured values to create a "Dwell Voltage Divider" going into the 12AT7.