Well, Hmm. Still not sure what to do... This choke does not fit in the position Sluckey suggested and may try the dry fit and see if it affects hum. What is the lowest choke current rating acceptable for 2 6L6's and 1 12AX7 and one 12AT7? I'm going to do some more reading...
From Aiken
If, on the other hand, you are selecting a choke for a capacitor input supply (such as the typical Marshall or Fender design), then the requirements are relaxed quite a bit. The purpose of the choke in these type supplies is not for filtering and voltage regulation, but just for filtering the DC supply to the screen grids of the output tubes and the preamp section. The screens typically take around 5-10mA each, and the preamp tubes draw about 1-2mA or so (for the typical 12AX7; 12AT7's are usually biased for around ten times that). This means that you can get by with a much smaller choke, and, in addition, the preamp supply current doesn't vary that much, so you can get by with a higher DC resistance, which means smaller wire can be used to wind the choke, which means higher inductance for a given size core. Just add up the current requirements of the screens and preamp tubes, and add a bit more for margin. For a 50W amp, a typical value might be 50-60mA.
So according to this I would need around 20ma for my 6L6's and 4ma for my 12AT7 and 12AX7 so it would seem that I could use a 4 Henry 75ma Choke and see if that fits a bit better.