So... ALL OF THIS seems to be a result of me wanting to keep all the values as I originally found them inside the amp. I thought that since this was a danelectro and not the silvertone 1344, slight variations would be expected. I wanted to know if it sounded good the way it was designed. Well I got my answer.
That first preamp tube 12sj7 was running about 30v on pin 8. Seemed way too low. Double checked all my R values according to what I documented on first opening the amp. What I put in the circuit was right according to my doc and the old Rs I pulled out. However, that low voltage can't be correct for proper amp operation. Looking at other 6sj7s examples, I saw 75vdc to 110vdc on pin 8. Way different. So i replaced those 75k Rs with 56k and lo-and-behold sooo much better. Still not perfect, but I actually get cleans on low volume, even with active humbuckers. Pin 8 is around 46.5vac now. I suspect i just need to bite the bullet and redo all the Rs based on the silvertone 1344 schematic.
I wish I new the story behind this amp. I don't know if it was some sort of failed prototype or someone's failed attempt at servicing it. There were also 2 or 3 resistors hanging out not accounted for compared to the silvertone circuit. Still don't know what they do, so I've removed them. But I feel like an idiot for not putting 2 and 2 together to start.

Thanks to you guys for guiding me even if I didn't listen right away
